Cash Balance Pension Plan

Overview, Pros and Cons

Cash Balance Pension Plan

What is a Cash Balance Pension Plan?

In retirement planning, a Cash Balance Pension Plan stands out as a unique fusion of traditional defined benefit pensions and modern defined contribution plans like 401(k)s. This plan involves employers setting up a hypothetical account for each employee, accumulating both salary-based pay and interest credit. Unlike 401(k) plans, where employees shoulder the investment risk, the employer assumes this responsibility, ensuring a guaranteed benefit upon retirement.

One significant advantage of Cash Balance Pension Plans is their higher contribution limits, which increase as employees age, making them particularly appealing to high-income earners who wish to maximize their retirement savings. Additionally, the tax-deferred nature of contributions and the flexibility for participants to choose between receiving their benefits as a lump sum or through lifetime annuity payments provide versatile options for accessing retirement funds.

Who Should Consider a Cash Balance Plan?

A Cash Balance Plan is a suitable option for a variety of individuals and businesses, particularly those looking to maximize their retirement savings and take advantage of significant tax benefits. Here are key groups who should consider a cash balance plan:

High-Income Business Owners

Business owners, especially those generating substantial income, often find cash balance plans attractive. These plans allow for much higher contribution limits than a 401(k), with annual contributions potentially exceeding $200,000 for individuals in their 50s and 60s, making them an ideal way to accelerate retirement savings and reduce taxable income.

Small Business Owners with Few Employees

Small businesses with fewer than 10 employees, particularly when the owner is older than the employees, can benefit from the flexible design of cash balance plans. The owners can allocate most contributions toward themselves while fulfilling minimal requirements for employee contributions.

Self-Employed Professionals

Cash balance plans are also well-suited for self-employed individuals or those in professional fields (e.g., doctors, lawyers). The ability to combine them with 401(k) plans allows professionals to maximize tax-deferred retirement savings.

This plan is especially beneficial for those nearing retirement who need to contribute larger amounts quickly and for business owners who want predictable costs and guaranteed retirement benefits.

Eligibility Criteria for Cash Balance Plan

To set up a Cash Balance Plan, businesses and self-employed individuals need to meet certain requirements to ensure proper setup and compliance. Here’s an overview:

1. Eligible Compensation: For businesses, contributions are usually calculated based on employee compensation. This is often W-2 wages for corporations or net profits from self-employment for sole proprietors (Schedule C) and partnerships (Schedule K-1). In 2023, the maximum compensation used for these purposes is $330,000.

2. Vesting and Participation: Cash balance plans require full vesting after no more than three years of service, typically following a “three-year cliff vesting” schedule. For small businesses with employees, at least the lesser of 50 employees or 40% of all employees must benefit from the plan.

3. Contribution Limits: Contributions are calculated based on age and compensation. For example, individuals in their 50s and 60s can contribute significantly more than younger participants. For a 60-year-old, contributions can exceed $320,000 annually.

4. Plan Permanency: Cash balance plans are intended to be permanent and must be maintained for at least five years to meet IRS guidelines. However, they can be terminated early due to business changes, such as a sale.

5. Actuarial Involvement: An actuary is required to calculate annual contribution amounts and ensure compliance with IRS regulations. The actuary also determines the interest credits and oversees the investment of plan assets.

For self-employed individuals or small business owners, cash balance plans can be a powerful retirement tool, offering large tax-deductible contributions while securing retirement benefits for both owners and employees.

Cash Balance Calculator

Is the business established for more than 10 years?(Required)
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Who should use Cash Balance Plan Calculator?

The Cash Balance Plan Calculator is an essential tool for individuals and businesses that meet specific financial criteria. It is particularly useful if you:

Earn More Than $100,000 Per Year:

High-income earners looking for ways to maximize their retirement contributions and take advantage of significant tax deductions can use the calculator to estimate their contribution limits under a cash balance plan.

Run a Business with Significant Free Cash Flow:

Business owners generating substantial cash flow may benefit from setting up a cash balance plan, which allows higher contributions and tax savings. The calculator helps determine the exact contribution amount based on income and age.

By using a “cash balance calculator”, you can receive a detailed contribution report that helps in planning your retirement savings effectively. It’s especially beneficial for professionals and business owners aiming to make substantial retirement contributions while minimizing tax liabilities.

For more accuracy, consulting with an actuary is recommended to design and administer the plan tailored to your specific financial situation.

Cash Balance Pension Plan VS 401(k) Plan

Feature Cash Balance Pension Plan 401(k) Plan
Type of Plan Defined Benefit Plan Defined Contribution Plan
Contribution Limits High limits based on age and salary (up to $300,000+) $23,000 in 2024, with a $7,500 catch-up contribution for 50+
Investment Risk Employer bears the risk Employee bears the risk
Control Over Investments Employer controls investments Employee controls investments

A Cash Balance Plan is best suited for high-income earners and business owners who want to contribute more to their retirement and need a guaranteed payout at retirement. A 401(k) Plan offers more flexibility and control but with more risk, as retirement income is not guaranteed and is tied to investment performance. Both plans offer unique advantages depending on individual financial goals and needs.

How to Set Up a Cash Balance Pension Plan?

To successfully establish a Cash Balance Pension Plan, several key steps must be followed before contributions can commence. Here’s a step-by-step guide:

Initial Calculation

Start by determining your potential contribution amount. Unlike 401(k) or profit-sharing plans, contributions for cash balance plans depend on the participant’s age and compensation history. While an online cash balance calculator can provide an estimate, a professional actuary must conduct the final calculation.

Collaboration with a CPA

Once you have an estimated contribution amount, engage your CPA to confirm that your business can support the plan financially. After agreeing on the contribution amount, the actuary will draft a customized plan document to align with your financial objectives.

Plan Documentation

An actuary must prepare the plan document, which details all assumptions and ensures conformity with IRS regulations. Typically, IRS pre-approval is needed, and a new Tax Identification Number (TIN) will be required as the pension plan functions as a separate legal entity.

Setting Up Investment Accounts

With the plan document ready, open a qualified investment account through a financial advisor or broker to ensure tax-deferred investment gains.

Making Contributions

Begin contributing after establishing the investment accounts. Adhere to the contribution range set by the actuary each year to prevent overfunding or underfunding. Contributions can be made until your business tax returns are filed.

Filing Annual Returns

Ensure compliance with IRS requirements by filing annual returns, such as Form 5500SF and Schedule SB, which need certification by an actuary. These filings cannot be submitted by your CPA or financial advisor. Non-compliance can result in penalties and plan disqualification.

Ongoing Compliance

Continuous compliance is necessary, with actuaries annually calculating contributions and filing necessary forms. Any changes in your financial situation should be communicated to the actuary for appropriate plan adjustments.

For self-employed individuals or business owners interested in setting up a cash balance plan, engaging a specialist is crucial. An actuary can offer personalized advice and design a plan to optimize retirement savings and tax benefits. Consider reaching out to Anthem Advice for expert guidance.

Combination of Cash balance pension plans with other plans

Combining a Cash Balance Pension Plan with other retirement plans, such as a 401(k), can offer substantial benefits for business owners, especially those seeking to maximize their retirement savings and tax deductions. Here’s how the combination works and why it’s an attractive option for many businesses:

Higher Contribution Limits

One of the biggest advantages of combining a cash balance plan with a 401(k) is the significantly higher contribution limits. A 401(k) plan alone allows for up to $23,000 (or $30,500 with catch-up contributions for those aged 50+) annually. However, when paired with a cash balance plan, contributions can exceed $300,000 per year, depending on the participant’s age and income.

For instance, a 65-year-old business owner can contribute up to $420,690 annually to both plans combined, which can result in considerable tax savings .

Tax Savings

Combining both plans offers substantial tax advantages. Contributions to both the 401(k) and the cash balance plan are tax-deferred, meaning they reduce taxable income. Businesses with high earnings can save significantly on taxes by maximizing contributions across both plans.

Flexibility for Employees and Owners

The 401(k) plan provides flexibility in terms of voluntary employee contributions, and the cash balance plan adds a defined benefit structure. This combination allows employers to offer a comprehensive retirement package. Business owners, in particular, benefit from the larger contribution limits, while employees still have access to a traditional 401(k) structure for their own retirement savings.

ERISA Protection

Both cash balance plans and 401(k) plans come with ERISA protections, ensuring that employees’ retirement savings are protected. This makes the combination an appealing option for businesses that want to attract and retain employees by offering robust retirement benefits.

Best for Certain Businesses

This combination is especially beneficial for professional groups like law firms, medical practices, and small businesses with predictable cash flow. Owners in these types of firms often look to maximize retirement savings and minimize taxes, making this strategy ideal.

In conclusion, combining a Cash Balance Plan with a 401(k) offers high-income earners and business owners a powerful tool to maximize retirement contributions and reduce tax burdens. However, this setup works best for businesses with stable cash flow and owners looking to significantly increase their retirement savings. Engaging with a financial or tax advisor is crucial to ensure that this combination fits your business needs.

Why to leverage Cash balance pension plan Contribution?

Cash balance pension plans offer flexibility in contributions, which makes them an attractive option for high-income earners and businesses with fluctuating cash flows. Here’s how contribution flexibility works:

Contribution Range

Each year, the employer is typically provided with a range of possible contributions, from a minimum to a maximum amount. This allows the business to adjust contributions based on cash flow or financial priorities for the year. For example, businesses can contribute on the lower end during lean years and increase contributions during profitable periods.

Higher Limits with Age

Contributions to cash balance plans increase with age, providing significant flexibility for older participants to accelerate retirement savings. In 2024, contributions for individuals over 60 can exceed $300,000 annually, far surpassing 401(k) limits.

Adjustable Contributions

While cash balance plans require an annual contribution, they provide some flexibility in how much to contribute each year, within IRS limits. The contributions are based on factors like compensation and age, allowing employers to tailor their contributions based on the needs of the business.

Integration with 401(k)

Combining a cash balance plan with a 401(k) allows businesses to maximize retirement savings. Employees can contribute to both plans, while the employer can decide on the contribution amounts, offering even greater flexibility in overall retirement funding.

This flexibility makes cash balance plans especially appealing for businesses with variable income, such as professional firms and small business owners nearing retirement.

Investment Strategies for Cash Balance Plans

When developing investment strategies for Cash Balance Plans, it’s crucial to balance risk management with the goal of meeting or exceeding the interest crediting rate promised to plan participants. Here are some general strategies often considered for managing investments in Cash Balance Plans:

Conservative Asset Allocation

Given that employers bear the investment risk, these plans typically favor conservative investments such as bonds and Treasury securities, which can offer stable returns that align with the plan’s interest crediting rate.

Diversification

To minimize risks, Cash Balance Plans often employ a diversified investment portfolio. This can include a mix of asset classes like equities, fixed income, and possibly alternative investments, depending on the plan’s risk tolerance.

Liability-Driven Investing (LDI)

This strategy focuses on aligning the investment portfolio with the plan’s liabilities, emphasizing asset classes that have similar characteristics to the liabilities (e.g., duration and maturity) to ensure that the plan can meet future obligations.

Risk Management

Incorporating risk management practices, such as using duration-matched bonds or interest rate swaps, helps to reduce exposure to interest rate fluctuations and other market risks.

Regular Assessment and Rebalancing

Continuous monitoring of the investment performance and periodic rebalancing of the portfolio is essential to ensure alignment with the investment strategy and to adjust for any changes in economic conditions or plan obligations.

Active and Passive Management

Depending on the financial goals and preferences, plans may choose between actively managed funds or passively managed index funds to achieve the desired balance of risk and return.

For specific advice or a tailored strategy, consulting Anthem Advice would be highly beneficial. Anthem Advice helps you align the investment strategy with the specific goals and regulatory requirements of the Cash Balance Plan.

Download the Cash Balance Guide

To learn more about how a cash balance plan can help you unlock huge tax savings while building a secure retirement, download our comprehensive Cash Balance Guide. This guide provides detailed insights into the benefits of cash balance plans, eligibility criteria, and how to set up a plan that works for you.